Q&A: Doesn't "The Tall Man" defy your advice on genre conventions? It sets up as a horror story, then subverts our expectations. Was that good writing, or just trickery?

You are viewing a clip of this video, click to Join. Members, click to Log in.

Bandwidth: High

Low

< >

Doesn't "The Tall Man" defy your advice on genre conventions? It sets up as a horror story, then subverts our expectations. Was that good writing, or just trickery?

Dec 03, 2012

Have you seen the new film "The Tall Man" starring Jessica Biel? I was impressed by it but wonder what you may think because it defies your advice on genre conventions. The film sets up a standard horror story only to completely subvert our expectations and our empathy for the protagonist half way through. Was that good writing in your view, or just trickery?

This is a Sample Member Question and Answer Page. Click here to become a member.

Q & A Discussion

Add Comment

When you sign up for Storylogue, you will also enjoy:

Can you explain the core event and the core emotion in the epic?
Aug 24, 2014

You say that one of the conventions of the comedy genre is that "nobody gets hurt," yet the creators of South Park seem to cross this line regularly. How do they get away with it?
Aug 23, 2014

What is the purpose of jumping back and forth between multiple storylines within a feature film or TV episode?
Aug 17, 2014

What characterizes a sado-masochistic relationship?
Aug 16, 2014

Do you have any tips for writing a treatment that really sells?
Aug 10, 2014

I'm unable to attend your TV Day lecture this year. Can you recommend any other good resources for television screenwriting?
Aug 09, 2014

How does writing an episode for a procedural crime show differ from writing a feature film thriller?
Jul 31, 2014

You say that all scenes are essentially dialogue. Can you explain this concept in the context of a long speech, which might traditionally be thought of as a monologue?
Jul 30, 2014

What's the best way to pitch a new story for television? Should I prepare a full script?
Jul 29, 2014

Do I have to be able to tell a story well verbally in order to be a good storyteller in my writing?
Jul 28, 2014

Username: *	Please enter the username used when registering for Storylogue
Password: *	Please enter your password
	or Create an Account

You are viewing a clip of this video, click to Join. Members, click to Log in.

Now Playing

Doesn't "The Tall Man" defy your advice on genre conventions? It sets up as a horror story, then subverts our expectations. Was that good writing, or just trickery?

This is a Sample Member Question and Answer Page. Click here to become a member.

Q & A Discussion

When you sign up for Storylogue, you will also enjoy:

Browse All Q&As >>>

You are viewing a clip of this video, click to Join. Members, click to Log in.

Now Playing

Doesn't "The Tall Man" defy your advice on genre conventions? It sets up as a horror story, then subverts our expectations. Was that good writing, or just trickery?

This is a Sample Member Question and Answer Page. Click here to become a member.

Q & A Discussion

When you sign up for Storylogue, you will also enjoy:

Browse All Q&As >>>

Forgot Password?

If you cannot find your password, enter your email here and we will send you a new password.